Polycrylic vs polyurethane reddit cabinets Polyurethane is, as the name implies, a urethane plastic. Resin would work. Polycrylic and I want to now cover it with polyurethane, as it has fully cured. At one point, you may have wondered, “Is Polycrylic the same as polyurethane?”, what is the difference between polyurethane and Polycrylic. buying new prefab white cabinets. Polycrylic vs. Conclusion So, as you can see, there is not one standard answer when it comes to the question 'Should I finish with polycrylic or polyurethane?' It all depends on: 1) how the piece will be used (high traffic pieces like a kitchen table - go with the more durable finish of polyurethane but a white painted nightstand in a master bedroom I pick polycrylic), 2) the other products you've used on the piece Oct 25, 2022 · October 25 . 3 coats is all you ought to need, might be able to get away with 2 coats. If it’s a high traffic piece of furniture, something that will come in contact with people and objects frequently, I would always use a polyurethane (or some form of film finish like lacquer, conversion varnish, etc. Polyurethane is more durable than polycrylic, but it is sensitive to extreme temperatures and Usually, this polish is not only used to give the wood a particular outlook but to also make it durable. I've never tried, but I think it would damage it. However I usually use oil based polyurethane and this just seems to be in a completely different tier as far as durability goes. They’re designed for indoor use and add a protective layer to your wood with similar results as polyurethane. Toxicity – polyurethane emits high levels of volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which are known to be bad for the environment as well as your health. I’d like some advice on which coatings are used for what reasons (polyurethane vs polycrylic vs oils?). I've read you need to lightly sand the surface first, but if I do that the bottom layer will look scratchy not smooth (it's black painted wood covered with polycrylic. Rustoleum - Maybe a slight brown toning, maybe. Started with the underside with brushes. 1K. ) Just an FYI, polyurethane is oil based polyurethane. Oct 31, 2024 · Polyurethane and Polycrylic are popular choices for protecting dining tables, but proper maintenance and care are crucial for preserving the beauty and longevity of your furniture. I started with the polyurethane clear gloss, switched to the plycrylic clear gloss, and then switched back. Posted by u/weeglos - 2 votes and 7 comments I want white cabinets and am debating between painting these existing ones vs. Minwax stains are very affordable at around $7-$15 per quart. ). Thank you This thread is archived I’m in the finishing stages of making a desk, with the top consisting of birch plywood. Both products offer excellent durability and protection against wear and tear, but they have some distinct differences that make them suitable for different applications. /r/finishing is a forum that encourages the respectful exchange of wood or metal finishing knowledge and projects Posted by u/kittteh00 - 6 votes and 11 comments I've seen some posts about polycrylic and polyurethane interacting with different paints. It is harder to work with and takes longer to cure than a water based polyurethane or polycrylic but is much more durable. Polycrylic can protect low indoor surfaces, such as cabinets or drawers, from scratches or moisture, but it can’t protect outdoor high-traffic surfaces. I built my computer desk from birch ply 20+ years ago, and applied multiple coats of oil-based Minwax poly, thinned a bit with turps. For a clear finish on pine, Polycrylic is an option. Everything talks about polycrylic having less VOCs but being trickier to apply but I’ve seen nothing definitive about whether a water based polyurethane is more protective than a polycrylic. Water based will keep the wood looking the same colour as it does now. A liquified plastic resin, polyurethane (often simply called poly) hardens after application. Do you mean water based polyurethane by polyurethane? If so, I totally agree with you. It has a nice matte finish, similar to butcher block. I wouldn't recommend polycrylic- it's waterbased and you need an oil based stain sealer thus the stains will probably still bleed through. I highly suggest minwax polycrylic vs polyurethane. Any input on either product would be appreciated as I am a complete novice. I’d look at a good water based polyurethane, if you don’t want the yellow tint. I’m going to spray some kitchen cabinets and I’ve been trying to research the difference in durability between polycrylic and water based polyurethane. Not sure about that 100% though. Thinned the poly, that helped a bit. While polyurethane and polycrylic are almost the same, there are some differences. vs oil-based polyurethane can be used on outdoor furniture or surfaces, with good resistance of water and heat. Cans are easier to use to get a good finish. If you wanted to try this I'd recommend the polyurethane or perhaps the helmsman oil. Jun 16, 2023 · Polyurethane vs. Exterior polyurethane offers weather resistance and protects the surface from outdoor elements, such as rain or UV rays. 4. However, it does not yellow over time and is easier to repair than polyurethane if it becomes damaged. Matte reflects almost no light, giving it a dull, low-sheen look. Both of these finishes offer excellent durability and protection against wear and tear, but they have some distinct differences that make them suitable for different applications. When it comes to protecting and enhancing the beauty of wood surfaces, two popular options are polycrylic and polyurethane. May 30, 2024 · Polycrylic is also moisture-resistant and can be applied in multiple thin coats. Similarities Both polycrylic and polyurethane offer good protection for your wood surface It depends. l buying spray cans and turn out well with practice. Both water-based polyurethane and polycrylic look the same and dry to a crystal clear hard finish. I've heard people say that there are some water based polys coming out in the last decade or two that are impressive when it comes to durability and can stand up against the traditional oil based polys but I haven't Feb 23, 2022 · Durability – polyurethane is more durable than polycrylic, which makes it a good choice for furniture and kitchen cabinets, outdoor pieces, or pieces that get lots of wear and tear. In fact, many of the same tips apply. While doing some woodwork, you may have to decide on which top coat to use between polycrylic and polyurethane. Both polyurethane and polycrylic are about the same as far as use and durability. Torn about which way to go. Typically, polycrylic costs about $20 to $30 per quart, and it's relatively safe to use because it is non-flammable and has a low level of VOCs . It also can go over oil-based finishes and can be applied using synthetic-bristle brushes, a foam roller or a rag, as can other water-based polyurethanes. 2) Curing - Should I let the nightstands cure for ~2 weeks before applying this topcoat? 3) Sanding - there are some blemishes in the paint around some corners of the trim. I like the polyurethane better because it lasts much longer. I’ve been doing this a long time and minwax is the only brand that has ever given me problems even waiting 1 week to dry! Maybe for small projects on closed grain wood it’s ok, but for large projects and especially open grained wood, I will never use it again. When it comes to oil-based polyurethane, you will find slightly higher durability than water-based polyurethane. Will be much happier with selection and performance. (2 or 3 is good). My 102 year old house still has the original doug fir floors that I refinished about 5 years ago using the old label "clear satin" polyurethane from Minwax. About 2 years ago I replaced a board and was able to use some I had leftover. Thanks! Apr 7, 2020 · Polycrylic doesn’t provide the same level of protection as polyurethane and doesn’t enhance the grain like oil-based polyurethane. When choosing between oil- and water-based spar urethane, another difference is that oil-based adds a sense of depth to the wood and makes the grain “pop,” whereas water-based products don’t offer this same effect. If you use water based don't use polycrylic, it's the least durable polyurethane I've ever used by far. Polyurethane has a yellowish tint to it once its dried, polycrylic dries clear. Aug 26, 2023 · When choosing between polycrylic vs polyurethane, consider the project needs in terms of wood type, desired sheen, use environment, durability needs, and application factors. Therefore, it’s challenging to say that one is better than the other. What is the difference between polycrylic and polyurethane? Polycrylic (water-based polyurethane) and polyurethane (oil-based polyurethane) are two popular topcoats used to protect furniture, cabinets and other surfaces. polyurethane is fine if you use stain because it just darkens it slightly. Introduction. If you put multiple coats of extra matte finish then it can get a little cloudy. For a bomb proof shell I like oil based polyurethane, it really lets the grain pop nicely too. However, water-based polyurethane may not be adequately resistant to heat and moisture. Both are good choices, the PolyWhey is probably tougher. It’s available in a range of sheens, as well as stain/poly combos. This makes it ideal for high-traffic areas I work at Lowes in paint, for anyone reading this years after this post was created, Minwax sells polycrylic and polyurethane is a spray can. My question is how can I get around this? Can I put the vinyl down and then water based polycrylic over it so the vinyl doesn't yellow and sticks? Rustoleum Varathane vs Minwax Polycrylic I'm trying to finish a birch desk top and want to apply a thin finish that won't discolor the wood, I'm stuck between Rustoleum and Minwax . Polycrylic is water-based and also tends to dry faster than polyurethane. Drawback is off gassing for days and long time between coats (24 hours). Polycrylic is thinner and so it can be runny so thin coats is a must. I'm finishing a bunch of t&g boards all 12' long, as well as some casing about 8' long, using water based polyurethane. Although there are different types of finish that can be used, polycrylic and polyurethane are the most common. 7 Coats needed to achieve a desirable outcome: polycrylic is thin and that’s why it always needs 6 to 8 coats to get a desirable outcome. I have used it and doing a couple coats of spray polycrylic in satin, semi-gloss, or high gloss definitely adds shine to a I find water-based polycrylic easier to work with and less messy. It comes in matte (my favorite) to gloss finishes. Its gloss level is between 30-40%. It shouldn’t be used in exterior applications or on surfaces that are subject to lots of wear, such as floors, or that are exposed to water. I'm new to finishing, and have some questions about Oil-based polyurethane vs Water-based polyurethane vs Polycrylic. While good urethane is quite oil-resistant, cheaper, poorly-formulated blends aren't, and will be attacked by oils over time. Polyurethane finish comes in two forms: water-based and oil-based. The drying and curing time is more for oil-based polyurethane than the water-based type, and it can vary from one manufacturer to another. Dec 21, 2024 · Polycrylic is not as durable as polyurethane and is meant to be used only on interior surfaces such as cabinets, furniture, and trim. Should I plan on lightly Im doing a big table right now. Polyurethane, conversely, offers longer-lasting durability and is ideal for furniture and floors, especially in high-traffic areas. Can anyone recommend a product for this? I haven’t found any polyurethane product that specifically says it’s compatible with paint. Is there a difference between water-based polyurethane and polyacrylic? When working with oil-based poly I've noticed a stronger lingering order is there a way to combat this? Anecdotically, I recently spilled some alcohol on a surface finished with polycrylic a few years ago and it burned through the finish. I couldn't scrape any away with fingernail. Polyurethane: Which is more waterproof? Neither is rated as waterproof, but they are both moisture-resistant. Then I gently scuffed the paint with 220 grit per on-line tutorials and applied the polycrylic. There are water-based hardwood floor finishes. Polyurethane is generally more durable and scratch-resistant, especially the oil-based variety. Polycrylic vs Polyurethane. Minwax Polycrylic is an example of a fortified water-based polyurethane that can stand up a bit better to rough conditions. If you insist on buying from BORG, try the Varathane WB Polyurethane for wood floors. The solvents evaporate from the material, which allows the oils and resin to harden Mar 4, 2022 · Polycrylic is water based, and polyurethane is oil based (though there are some water based polyurethanes). This should make adding thin coats a while lot easier compared to using a brush. Sep 17, 2015 · Polyurethane is a protective finish that is available in both oil based and water based forms. Let’s jump in! Then go to Benjamin Moore or Ace and get a product called Cabinet coat by Insl X it's a really high quality coat for trim cabinets doors and special finishes. They even make a version for floors. Polycrylic stays clear, will not yellow. I would not use shellac as a topcoat for any surfaces exposed to regular use such as table tops, or ones with the risk of exposure to water and/or I’m looking to apply a clear coat or a polyurethane product over wood that was painted with water based latex paint. I've also been told (by a cabinet maker) that these are cheap plywood and no more than 30 years old. Sep 26, 2024 · Frequently Asked Questions about Polycrylic and Polyurethane Which is better, polyurethane or polycrylic? When it comes to choosing between polyurethane and polycrylic, it depends on your specific needs. Apr 25, 2024 · Polycrylic vs. Gets that texture smoother. When it comes to protecting and enhancing the beauty of wood surfaces, two popular options are polyurethane and Varathane. Polycrylic finish is based on water only. I’m going to spray some kitchen cabinets and I’ve been trying to research the difference in durability between polycrylic and water based polyurethane. It'll add a richness and warm tone. How long does polycrylic take to dry? Polycrylic typically dries to the touch in a couple of hours, but it’s recommended to wait at least 24 hours before applying additional coats. Minwax old modified water based polyurethane - Way stronger than the others. It is pretty good, but not as tough as oil based. The only area showing significant wear is on the keyboard tray, where the mouse rides (through the veneer there). As the water evaporates from the resin, the material transforms from a liquid into a film. the 3-7 days polycrylic takes. Topcoats like their High Performance Polyurethane cost around $25-$35 per quart. Finished with a high quality color product of white (Swiss Mocha). Polyurethane, unlike polycrylic, also has a tendency to yellow over time and when exposed to lots of UV rays. It cleans up with water (no mineral spirits, yay!) and doesn't destroy brushes the way polyurethane has, in my experience. There are differences between these two finishes that will affect your project. Nov 14, 2022 · Polycrylic finishes are water-based products you may not be as familiar with. Jul 23, 2023 · Polycrylic has running consistency, which makes it hard to apply on vertical surfaces. Mar 28, 2020 · If you using gallons of top coat, you should be using an industrial Finishes supplier. Wipe on polyurethane is easy to apply and will give you pretty good water resistance, however particle board is horrible with water, so you're going to have problems if it's in constant contact with water. /r/DIY is for all things Do-It-Yourself **Please see the following rules** * Everything submitted must be DIY… Can anyone offer advice on what type of gloss I should finish my boards with? I see alot of people using polycrylic semi-gloss but I really want my boards to stand out so I bought just the regular polycrylic gloss. Another option is PolyWhey which is also a clear film finish that is polyurethane made from cheese whey. All three are very durable. What is Polyurethane? Water-based polyurethane finishes are comprised of a resin suspended in water and solvent. Mar 30, 2023 · On the other hand, water-based spar urethane dries crystal clear, so your wood’s color will shine through. Polycrylic is a Minwax water-based top coat not to be used on floors. Here are some pros and cons of polyurethane vs polycrylic. At first, I was told these cabinets were original to the home (from 1910) and solid wood. Oil based is more durable eventually and resistant to chemicals. How to Use Polycrylic? Applying Polycrylic is pretty similar to Polyurethane. For this information, you will focus solely on the differences between epoxy and polyurethane and how they’re used in the most typical applications. Because there is so much flattening agent in a matte finish, it will build up over multiple coats and create a cloudy appearance (probably what you have heard of regarding the white appearance)To avoid that you have to use a gloss sheen for the first couple of coats and then finish with the matte sheen Minwax Polycrylic/General finishes high performance top coat extremely soft - completely at wits end Hi back again, with continuing troubles with water based finishesfml. with cabinet coat you can do a one coat finish and it's really high quality stuff what you do Mar 2, 2022 · 3. There is also ScuffX and InsulX Cabinet Coat which are common urethanes used on cabinets. Can get Gemini WB polyurethane for < $60/gal that performs better than both of the above (those acrylics are too soft IMHO). Water based polyurethane is a latex with polyurethane mixed into the latex molecules. The polycrylic does not stand up to the bags being thrown on them. Satin is also a low-sheen finish, but it reflects more light, making it slightly shinier. I strongly recommend sanding between the clearcoat and and your prime coat. polyurethane assessment. Toughness was same as polycrylic (next), read that. Sep 27, 2024 · What Is Polyurethane Wood Finish? If you think “polyurethane” sounds like the name of a plastic, you’re absolutely right. It can help protect the paint and enhance the durability of the finish. Polycrylic may take a while to cure (products vary but roughly 3 hours for light handling), so touching or placing anything on your freshly-coated wood might leave indentations. Shellac and the powder both dissolve in denatured alcohol, so since you were already considering it that could be one way to go… but I’d recommend dewaxed (sometimes sold as sanding sealer) because I have seen cabinets where a coffee machine was belching steam up the face of the cabinet a couple times a day and the waxed shellac ended up We run a small lumber mill and make tables and bar tops and things. It dries way faster and is easier to use. Welcome to r/AustralianNostalgia, a subreddit dedicated to evoking memories of Australia's past! This online community is a vibrant hub where Aussies and those intrigued by Australian culture come together to reminisce and share nostalgic moments from days gone by. Unless you have the knowledge and tools to deal with safely exhausting highly flammable fumes do not use pre cat. Since water based poly is the top coat of my choice I use dewaxed shellac under it to bring out the wood figure. Nov 27, 2021 · (Read Joint Compound Vs Spackle) Which is Better Polycrylic or Polyurethane? When choosing wood finishes, you will most likely hear of the most versatile sealers you can use on wooden flooring and furniture: polycrylic and polyurethane. Polycrylic is easier to apply and dries faster, but it may not provide as durable a finish as polyurethane. Sep 20, 2023 · The key difference between matte and satin polyurethane is the appearance. Polyurethane is somewhat more durable (honestly I couldn’t tell you there’s a big difference), but this will really only be a benefit to use in high humidity enclosures or idk, just personal preference. All in all 2/5, I would not recommend for a table top. Polyurethane. The cabinets are all done with WB Polycrylic - they look fine too. Both Polyurethane and Polycrylic have similar names and are used as topcoats for wood projects. However, it’s an excellent choice for surfaces where durability against moisture and heat isn’t a concern, such as desks, side tables, bookcases, picture frames, home decor projects, and more. In the sections below, I compare polycrylic vs polyurethane and help you decide when you should use each product. Oil-based polyurethane cures in a slightly different way. I'm wanting to paint my car but don't have the relevant respirators for 2K I am going to use a water based polyurethane on Friday so the mineral spirits will have plenty time to thoroughly evaporate. Lacquer is the standard but does not hold up as well, especially wet areas like around sinks, dries fast though so you can spray multiple coats in a day. Here you can see the differences to find which is better in our polycrylic vs. She said the oil based urethane will eat away at the adhesive on the vinyl. Its dry in about an hour and is ready for a other coat. One of the main distinctions between these two finishes is their chemical composition. That's the only negative for me. General Finishes stain prices range from $10-$20 for a quart. That’s when all hell broke loose! Suddenly every brushstroke, scuff, etc in the cabinets 70 years on earth seemed to seep up through the primer, paint, and polycrylic. Even maybe just a link with some information would be helpful. I used left over oil based polyurethane and my vinyl connect said that the vinyl won't stick to it. I use regular shellac only for insides of clothes cabinets but I used dewaxed a lot. Its fully waterproof and leaves no rings or anything. it comes in satin and semi-gloss I would recommend cabinet coat instead of that bear paint. The space I'm doing it in is… Introduction. Matte’s gloss level is between 15-30%. Im wondering about the residue and what the effect is when I apply the poly. Polycrylic offers fast-drying convenience while polyurethane provides ultimate durability. Oil based polyurethane will stand up the best to heat and water. It'll not yellow. However Polyurethane off-gases much more than polycrylic and takes weeks to completely cure vs. 1k is fine for most applications, similar durability to advance/emerald urethane and professionals spray cabinets all the time with those products. Cleaning Procedures. I want to make sure I'm headed down the right path. All articles said urethane was less durable and dried with yellow tint. In the beginning stages of your woodworking endeavors, it can be challenging to determine if you need epoxy or polyurethane resins. I’ve done some research online but so far it’s only muddied the waters. Feb 10, 2024 · Frequently Asked Questions For Polycrylic Vs Polyurethane Which Is Better Polycrylic Or Polyurethane? Polycrylic is better suited for indoor projects; it dries faster and emits less odor. Woodworking is your worldwide home for discussion of all things woodworking, carpentry, fine furniture, power tools, hand tools, and just about anything else about making - anything - from trees! View community ranking In the Top 10% of largest communities on Reddit Cellulose vs Polyurethane Enamel . 23M subscribers in the DIY community. Polycrylic - It's known for being transparent 100% and it is. Polyurethane varnishes can be used on models, but I prefer to stick with acrylics as they dry incredibly fast and provide nearly as good protection if you use gloss varnish first. The resin "Water-based polyurethane" is actually mostly acrylic with just a little bit of polyurethane added for extra toughness. The same is actually true of oil-based poly too, except with alkyd resin instead of acrylic. Polycrylic. They are way cheaper than. Polycrylic will get removed or washed off if exposed to constant water With my experience, I've used both. It comes in 2 varieties – glossy and satin finish. Oil based polyurethane is the toughest one part finish you can buy. I've always used polycrylic because what you see before you put it on is exactly what you see after. Anytime I do polycrylic i give it a quick rundown with bowling alley wax/paste wax. Jan 12, 2023 · A finish can make floors, cabinets, and crafts look better than before, but only if you choose the right one. . Polycrylic doesn’t handle high heat well, as well. I chose Minwax polycrylic to finish because I wanted something more durable than wax but something a little easier to handle than polyurethane, since I have a small space. com Polycrylic is not as durable as polyurethane and is meant to be used only on interior surfaces such as cabinets, furniture, and trim. I’m leaning more towards a poly product for its durability, hardness and slick feel. Feb 21, 2024 · Cons of Polycrylic . Its extremely forgiving and extremely easy to apply vs regular poly. I recently came across The one coat polyurethane and the water based polycrylic and wanted to know if either of these would be a good replacement for the cans I have been using. Was expensive brush, still left hairs in it, and also brush marks. See full list on bobvila. Is it too much? Will the glare from the sun or lights at night be bad for seeing the boards? Anyone offer any advice? Thanks! My plan was to sand the thick and scratched top coat off (chemical strippers didn't even faze it), then put some kind of oil that brings out the color back to how it looked initially, then seal it with spray semi-gloss polyurethane (which I have lots of already), and finally, cover it all with bar-top epoxy. When cleaning a dining table coated with polyurethane or polycrylic, use a soft, damp cloth to wipe away dust and spills. I haven’t used polyurethane for this application. Mar 6, 2024 · Water-based polyurethane, like polycrylic, can be cleaned with soap and warm water, but oil-based polyurethane needs to be cleaned with mineral spirits or paint thinner. It just feels impressive. Jul 15, 2022 · Polycrylic vs Polyurethane Are Polycrylic and Polyurethane the Same Thing? No, polyacrylic and Polyurethane are not the same. I bought a set of drawers already painted with graphite chalk paint, but it didn't have any finish on it. polyurethane: what’s the difference? The Cabinet Coat satin finish attracts and holds dirt like crazy so I applied Minwax Polyacrylic Semigloss over top of the INSL-X. Especially if water is involved. You just get a good brush, and apply as many light (and I mean very light) layers as you'd like. Reply reply I use polycrylic all the time, between each coat do a light sanding with a 220 grit sandpaper, doesnt need to take too long. We use waterloxx. On the other hand, polyurethane offers excellent durability but requires more time for application and drying. When comparing polycrylic and polyurethane, you will find that both finishes provide a protective barrier with varying degrees of protection. Their wipe-on polyurethanes cost just $15-$20 per quart. Depending on the wood projects you are coating, one may be better than the other. It is a film finish and it is actually clear acrylic paint. Sep 15, 2024 · Polycrylic and polyurethane have their own set of pros and cons. Water-based polyurethane is famous for being low odor and low toxic. So I went with Minwax polycrylic. Can I use polycrylic over chalk paint? Yes, polycrylic can be used over chalk paint. I wanted to seal and protect the paint so I did my research on polycrylic vs. Nov 24, 2022 · Which Is Better – Polyurethane vs Polycrylic? Choosing between using polycrylic or an oil-based polyurethane finish depends on the type of finish you require. Also, I'm pretty sure that you don't want to push polyurethane through an airbrush. Both products have their advantages and disadvantages. They seal, add a shine to wooden surfaces, but they are used in different cases. For the past month I've been trying to figure out how to finish a table I stupidly built out of cedar, and am at my wits end with trying to finish it. “Both are waterproof in the short-term, but over longer timelines, polycrylic and water-based polyurethane will degrade faster than an oil-based polyurethane formulation,” says Walker. But, this could theoretically work. On the other hand, polyurethane can be oil-based or water-based. Has a very slight brown toning to it. The polycrylic made the paint so much darker. So, what is the difference between polycrylic and polyurethane? Polycrylic contains a water base and polyurethane is made with an oil base. It is essentially Polycrylic paint minus the weirdness of putting a clear coat over paint. Tested brushing vs spraying and landed on spray because of brush marks. It does yellow over time though. And it will be thicker and a higher barrier to get it going. Thus the recommendation of Emerald Urethane or for a Ben Moore product Rust Scat. cuqlp igfvtjmhu wam mzrmo jdpfin sfhjmka zhwmoq diwva qnukyz ayalcf